I cannot say I am surprised, but I'm hardly going to throw the staff under the bus on this one. I actually think they played their hand perfectly...
1. Any time a 5 star recruit, and top PG wants to commit to your program you gladly take him. I don't care what program you are, you take him, PERIOD. The SU staff DID!
2. Any time a 16 year old makes a commitment you also continue to recruit other players at the position, with the understanding that 16 year olds are notoriously fickle and immature. The SU staff IS! We're still recruiting other guards (JJ, Roddy, Lindsay, etc... am I missing anyone?) and we'll likely add others to our list.
3. Anytime a 16 year old verbal commit starts to show evidence of wobbling on his commitment to school, you move on as amicably and as quickly as possible (and leave the door open in the future). The SU staff DID! It was a mutual decision, and it sounds like Dior hasn't eliminated SU, though I suspect he'll never play a minute of college ball.
So I'm just going to say it... does it suck to lose a 5 start recruit. Of course... but the staff handled this situation perfectly. Because if Dior was standing in way of Roddy's commitment, then kudos to the staff that recognized that you'll take a commitment from a 4 star guy rated as highly as Gayle any day over running the risk of being left at the alter by a 5 star recruit who's track record is pretty unreliable. I'm truly hopeful this gives us a chance to win over Roddy. I actually think our style of play favors Roddy over Dior anyhow.
It is truly much better that this ended now than in a year. This is NOT a bad thing guys. We'll be fine, plus Kadary is looking really good.