I disagree actually. I posted in another thread but Benny Williams would be Virginia's highest rated player in years. Our recruiting is down but the problem is our style of play and player development IMO.
I would agree - everything is an issue right now.
However, if you look at it from a historical perspective, our top 2-3 players have always been recruits in the range of 1 (Carmelo) to 50.
Starting in 1992-93 (Some 90's years are tough but should be pretty accurate):
'92-93 - McRae, Wallace & Autry (McD All-Americans), Moten
'93-94 - Wallace, Autry (McD A-A), Gelatt (4th Team Parade All-American)
'94-95 - Wallace, Autry, Michael Lloyd (Top JUCO Player in Country)
'95-96 - Wallace
'96-97 - Lloyd (Top 30), Hart (Top 50)
'97-98 - Blackwell (Top 20), Hart, Griffin (Top 50)
'98-99 - Blackwell, Hart, Griffin, Bland (Top 40)
'99-00 - Blackwell, Hart, Griffin, Bland, D. Williams (Top 50)
'00-01 - Griffin, Williams
'01-02 - Williams (NIT)
'02-03 - Carmelo (Top 2), McNamara (Top 40), Edelin (Top 40)
'03-04 - McNamara, Edelin, Nichols (#31), Watkins (#34), Roberts (#42)
'04-05 - McNamara, Edelin (kinda), Nichols, Watkins, Roberts, J. Wright (#36)
'05-06 - McNamara, Nichols, Watkins, Roberts, J. Wright, Devendorf (McD A-A, Top 20)
'06-07 - Nichols, Watkins, Roberts, J. Wright, Devendorf, Harris (Top 25), Mike Jones (#44)
'07-08 - Wright (sorta), Devendorf, Harris, Flynn (McD A-A), D. Greene (McD A-A), Jardine (#50)
'08-09 - Devendorf, Harris, Flynn, Jardine, Mookie Jones (#46)
'09-10 - Jardine (4 Top 60 Players plus Transfer from Big 12)
'10-11 - Jardine, Melo (McD A-A), Waiters (Top 25)
'11-12 - Melo, Waiters, Christmas (McD A-A), MCW (#25)
'12-13 - Christmas, MCW, Coleman (McD A-A), Grant (#41)
'13-14 - Christmas, Coleman, Grant, Ennis (#23), Roberson (#37), Gbinije (#28)
'14-15 - Christmas,
Coleman, Gbinije, Roberson, McCullough (McD A-A)
'15-16 - Coleman, Gbinije, Roberson, Richardson (McD A-A)
'16-17 - Coleman, Roberson, Battle (#31), White (#52)
'17-18 - Battle
'18-19 - Battle, Carey (#52)
'19-20 - Carey
'20-21 - None