People have really short memories.
Yes, Roberson was huge on our Final Four run by averaging nearly 12 boards per game in the Tourney. But he's also the same player whom Boeheim said "If I had anyone else, he wouldn't play."
I get the Senior loyalty thing. But it's not an automatic. In fact, there have been a few players over recent history that did not start as Seniors (a couple of which despite having started the majority of games the previous year).
*Billy Celuck
Jeremy McNeil
Matt Gorman
*Josh Wright
Kristof Ongenaet (JUCO)
James Southerland (didn't start until Coleman went down with injury)
Baye Keita
Lydon, meanwhile, could have easily been a first-round pick last June if he had decided to leave. He did Boeheim and the program a favor by staying. Boeheim is not going to reward that decision by putting him on the bench to start games. Lydon has National POY potential and barring an injury this is going to be his final season. HE'S GOING TO START.
IMO Roberson has the perfect personality to handle going from starter to 6th man. He won't throw a chair at Boeheim in the locker room or fight teammates in practice. And coming off the bench is generally less pressure than starting the game. Maybe lessen the nerves. As a result I would expect him to respond extremely well to such a role.